Which statement correctly contrasts devolution with federalism?

Prepare for the UK Politics Test with our comprehensive quiz. Test your knowledge with flashcards and multiple choice questions, each with hints and explanations. Ace your exam!

Multiple Choice

Which statement correctly contrasts devolution with federalism?

Explanation:
The key idea is how power is arranged between the centre and subnational bodies. Devolution happens in a unitary state when the central government transfers some powers to subnational bodies, like Scotland, Wales, or Northern Ireland, but the central government still retains ultimate sovereignty. Those devolved powers can be changed or withdrawn by the central parliament, and the subnational bodies don’t have independent sovereignty equal to the centre. That’s why the statement describing devolution as transferring powers within a unitary state to subnational bodies is the best fit. It reflects that devolution operates inside a unitary framework, unlike federal systems where powers are constitutionally divided and both levels have defined sovereignty within their own spheres. The other descriptions describe federalism, or claim the UK is federal by design, or claim devolved regions have sovereign equality with the centre, which isn’t the case.

The key idea is how power is arranged between the centre and subnational bodies. Devolution happens in a unitary state when the central government transfers some powers to subnational bodies, like Scotland, Wales, or Northern Ireland, but the central government still retains ultimate sovereignty. Those devolved powers can be changed or withdrawn by the central parliament, and the subnational bodies don’t have independent sovereignty equal to the centre.

That’s why the statement describing devolution as transferring powers within a unitary state to subnational bodies is the best fit. It reflects that devolution operates inside a unitary framework, unlike federal systems where powers are constitutionally divided and both levels have defined sovereignty within their own spheres. The other descriptions describe federalism, or claim the UK is federal by design, or claim devolved regions have sovereign equality with the centre, which isn’t the case.

Subscribe

Get the latest from Passetra

You can unsubscribe at any time. Read our privacy policy